From within the first winds
Of spring
Until the final winds
Of winter
I gazed into a mountain pool,
Steadfast there daily
'Til I gained an Audience
With the Spirit
And from these Waters
At which I'd stared so long
Now at last the moment had come
To request admission
To more deeply enter
The womb of things.
I spoke silently this question
That had weighed me to a rock
On which I had gravidly sat in meditation
For three whole seasons when
At last the Waters within me
Burst
"Why am I the Answer?"
The pool lay still and mute,
Not a ripple upon its face.
Totally absorbed,
It absorbed this outflow
Of thought, of birth,
Of birth of no-thought.
Yet herewith
My reflection interrupted,
Mirrored on the still pool,
My face,
He who had sired this meditation
And who quickened before my eyes as its child.
Semi-opaquely spoke,
"And why am I the Question?"
I moaned as if in labor
And my pain sank to the depths.
"I've been trying and
Trying to Answer
That Question."
Every surface my eyes weighed
Seemed
but to grimace
As I strained to give birth to
A new understanding of myself
Hereupon
The Spirit of the Waters
Arose from the bottom
And in utter stillness said,
"The Wild Geese do not intend to cast an image,
The Water has no mind to reflect them".
I sank into these words
That ushered from the depths of the pool
And saw myself and said,
"My reflection and I
Are confused in our mixture.
Which one is real?
Thereof
The Spirit spoke again saying,
"Both and Neither.
Not both and not neither.
Travel the middle way.
I support you both
As I am the Source
Of both of you.
This is always immediate, always present.
Do you question this?"
Hastily, my reflection spoke forthwith.
"Can you return us to
Our Source?"
Slowly and deeply
The Spirit of the Waters
Quietly gave this sentence to my reflection.
"That which can be returned to sources
Is clearly not you.
That which can be returned to nowhere
Is none other than you".
The Spirit paused. I strained to hear below its surface
As it again intoned:
"Only you, sire-child of reflection,
Clearly understand this
And that is why you are so close to me."
And my reflection smiled.
Thereupon I said,
"But you never said which of us is real.
You never answered my question."
Thereat
my reflection interposed,
"Yes, you never said why
He is the Answer
And why
I am the Question
And why it is
I understand his Answer
But
He doesn't understand my Question."
Once
more, yet final,
The Spirit of The Waters spoke hereat,
Saying,
"The Question is a mirror for the Answer.
Together you always
Question the Answer
And
Answer the Question."
"Know that your are both
The Question and the Answer
And thus,
Arise dependent upon One Another
Until the moment arrives
You should come to share the same conclusion."
"In the interval before then,
What it is that is
Between you
Is the solution
You should turn to
That you both might at last
Come to conclusion in me,
For only I am
Beyond all Questions and Answers."
And I arose from my long meditation,
Many seasons having passed
Along with perhaps many lives
In an instant
And I looked into the pool in the stream
Which now shone with emptiness....
I stood up and walked on,
The reflections of the World sparkling in my eyes...
Note: This poem arose after reading the Surangama sutra and attending temple lectures on the
100 Verses of Vasubandu.
It was written at the conclusion of the Winter of '93 Practice Period at
Tasajara Mountain Retreat, San Francisco Zen Center.